Why Does Our Live Stream Sound Different From What People Hear in Church?

(Why Your Online Mix Needs Its Own Mix)

By Dawie Nolte · Nolte Productions

One of the things that often gets overlooked when setting up a church streaming system is that the sound in the building and the live stream sound going out online are two different things.

I often hear complaints from churches that have recently started streaming. Everything sounds good in the building, the congregation is happy, but someone watching from home complains that the pastor sounds too far away, the singing is too loud, or some of the instruments are hardly audible.

The first reaction is often to think that something is wrong with the sound system. In many cases, there is nothing wrong with the equipment. The problem is simply that the audio going to the stream has not been mixed properly for the people listening online.

Your Sound in the Building and Your Live Stream Sound Are Two Different Things

When mixing for the church, you are working with a combination of sound coming from the PA system and sound that people hear directly in the room.

For example, someone sitting in the congregation can hear an acoustic piano, guitar or other instruments directly from the stage, as well as through the PA system. They also hear the congregation singing around them. All of this contributes to what they experience in the building.

Someone watching the service online does not have that same experience. They only hear what is being sent to the streaming platform through their phone, television or computer.

This means that a mix that sounds perfectly balanced in the church can sound completely different to someone listening at home.

Why Sending the Main Mix Straight to the Stream Doesn’t Always Work

One of the easiest ways to get audio from the mixer to the streaming computer is to take a feed from the main output of the desk.

In a very small and simple setup, this might work reasonably well. However, it is often where the problems start.

Your main mix has been set up to make the PA system sound good in the building. The levels of the instruments, vocals and microphones have been adjusted with the congregation and the acoustics of the room in mind.

I’ve worked with setups where an acoustic piano, acoustic guitar or even an electric or bass guitar through its own amplifier is clearly audible in the room. The sound comes partly through the PA and partly directly from the instrument or amplifier on stage.

If that same instrument is low in the main mix, the people watching online might hardly hear it at all.

The instrument isn’t necessarily missing from the church sound. It is simply not coming through properly on the stream.

Set Up a Separate Mix for the Stream

The best solution is to create a separate audio mix specifically for the live stream.

Most digital mixers, including fairly basic models, have the ability to send an independent mix to another output. This is normally done using an AUX bus or another suitable mix bus, depending on the mixer and its routing capabilities.

This allows you to adjust the stream mix without changing what the congregation hears through the PA system.

For example:

  • Keep the pastor’s microphone clear and at a comfortable level so that people listening on a phone or television can hear every word.
  • Adjust the worship leader and backing vocals so that they sit properly in the online mix.
  • Bring the instruments up to levels that work for the stream, even if those levels are different from what you need in the building.
  • Add some congregation sound so that people watching online can still experience the service and hear the congregation singing.

The important thing is that you can make these adjustments independently of the main PA mix.

You are using the same mixer, but creating two different mixes for two different audiences.

If the pastor still sounds thin or boomy on the stream, a small EQ adjustment usually sorts it out, and I’ve put some good starting points in Where and How Should I Set the EQ?. And if the pastor sounds far away no matter what you do, look at how the microphone is being held before you touch the mixer. It’s Probably Not the Sound System — It’s How You’re Holding the Mic explains why that matters so much.

Check That Every Microphone and Instrument Is Going to the Stream

This is the first thing I would check.

Just because a microphone or instrument can be heard in the church does not mean that it is automatically coming through properly on the stream.

As mentioned earlier, an acoustic instrument or guitar amplifier might be clearly audible in the building, even if its microphone channel is turned down in the main mix. The congregation can still hear the instrument directly from the stage, but the online audience cannot.

Go through each microphone and instrument individually and make sure that it is actually routed to the stream mix and that its level is correct.

Don’t assume that everything is working just because the main PA sounds good.

Remember, the two mixes need to be checked separately.

A Little Room Sound Makes a Difference

A live stream does not have to sound like a studio recording. Part of the experience of watching a church service is hearing the congregation singing, clapping and responding.

A separate ambient microphone can help capture some of this sound and add a sense of atmosphere to the stream.

However, be careful not to use too much of it. Too much room sound can make the stream muddy and bring in unnecessary background noise and reverberation.

Also, if the ambient microphone is feeding the PA system, you need to be aware of the possibility of feedback.

A little room sound is usually enough. The idea is to give the online audience a better sense of what is happening in the building without overpowering the rest of the mix.

Getting the Sound to the Computer

Once the stream mix is sorted out, you also need to make sure that the audio is reaching the streaming computer correctly.

Some mixers have a built-in USB audio interface, while others require an external audio interface to get the signal into the computer.

There are a few basic things to check:

  • Make sure that the correct output from the mixer is connected to the computer.
  • Check that the computer is using the correct audio input device.
  • Check that your streaming software, such as OBS, is receiving audio from the correct input.
  • Make sure that the computer hasn’t selected its built-in microphone instead of the mixer input.

It is worth checking this before every service. I’ve seen situations where everything was connected correctly, but the computer had selected the wrong audio input.

Also remember that the levels you see on your mixer are not necessarily the same levels reaching your streaming software.

Listen to the actual audio going into the computer using headphones, or preferably watch the stream on another device, such as a phone. This gives you a much better idea of what the online audience is actually hearing.

And if no audio is reaching the stream at all, don’t start changing things at random. Work through the signal chain one step at a time, the way I describe in No Sound? Don’t Panic — Here’s How to Find the Problem.

Test Everything Before the Service Starts

The best habit I can recommend is to test the actual live stream before the congregation arrives.

Don’t just check that the PA system is working. Listen to the stream mix separately.

Go through the pastor’s microphone, worship leader, backing vocals and all the instruments. Check that everything is coming through at the correct level.

Also check that the audio and video are in sync.

If possible, ask someone who is not operating the mixer to watch the test stream and give you feedback. What you hear at the mixer is not always what someone watching from home will hear.

A few minutes of testing before the service can save you from discovering halfway through the service that something isn’t working properly.

A Few Things to Remember

✔ Your main PA mix and your stream mix serve two different audiences.

✔ Use a separate AUX or other suitable mix bus for the stream where your mixer allows it.

✔ Check that every microphone and instrument is routed correctly to the stream.

✔ Don’t rely on the main mix to give you the correct balance for online listeners.

✔ Use an ambient microphone if needed, but don’t overdo it.

✔ Monitor the actual audio going to the streaming computer.

✔ Test the stream before the service starts, not just the PA system.

Do You Need New Equipment?

In most cases, probably not.

Many churches already have a mixer that can handle a separate stream mix. The problem is often simply that this facility has not been set up or used correctly.

Before spending money on new equipment, first look at your existing mixer and check what it can do.

You might already have everything you need to get a much better result.

If your current mixer cannot provide an independent output, or you need more inputs or routing options, then it might be time to look at other solutions.

Start with what you have. Get the routing right, set up a proper stream mix and test it before the service. You might be surprised at how much difference this makes.

Good sound in the church does not automatically mean good sound online. Both need attention.

If you need help setting up a separate stream mix on your existing mixer, or you are struggling to get the sound right for your online audience, Nolte Productions would be happy to assist.

— Dawie Nolte

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top